Iraq conflict has cost 1.2 million lives, claims civilian survey

Iraq conflict has cost 1.2 million lives, claims civilian survey

Peter Beaumont
London Observer
September 16, 2007

A startling new household survey of Iraqis released last week claims as many as 1.2 million people may have died because of the conflict in Iraq – apparently lending weight to a 2006 survey in the Lancet that reported similarly high levels.

More than one million deaths were already being suggested by anti-war campaigners, but such high counts have consistently been rejected by US and UK officials. The estimates, extrapolated from a sample of 1,461 adults around the country, were collected by a British polling agency, ORB, which asked Iraqis how many people living in their household had died as a result of the violence rather than from natural causes.

Previous estimates, most prominently collected by the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, reported in Lancet in October 2006, suggested almost half this number, 654,965, as a likely figure in a possible range of 390,000 to 940,000.

Although the household survey was carried out by a polling organisation, rather than by epidemiological researchers operating under the discipline of scientific peer review, it has again raised the spectre that the 2003 invasion of Iraq has caused a far more substantial death toll than officially acknowledged by the US or UK governments or the Iraqi Ministry of Health.

The ORB survey follows an earlier report by the organisation which suggested one in four Iraqi adults had had a family member killed. Their latest survey suggests that in Baghdad that number is as high as one in two. The poll also questioned the surviving relatives on how their loved ones were killed. It reveals 48 per cent died from a gunshot wound, 20 per cent from the impact of a car bomb, nine per cent from aerial bombardment, six per cent by accident and six per cent from another blast or ordnance.

If true, the latest figures would suggest the death toll in Iraq now exceeds that of the Rwandan genocide when 800,000 died.

The new effort to estimate the number of dead in Iraq is certain to reignite the controversy over the lack of any proper accounting of the number of civilian dead in Iraq, rejected by US commander General Tommy Franks who said: ‘We don’t do death counts.’ The problem has been exacerbated by the unwillingness of the Iraqi government to release proper accounting of the death toll which has led to suspicion of the figures being estimated deliberately downwards.

An absolute minimum of just under 80,000 deaths has been established by the British group Iraq Body Count. The Lancet survey was criticised by some experts and rubbished by George Bush and British officials. In private, however, the Ministry of Defence’s chief scientific adviser Sir Roy Anderson described it as ‘close to best practice’.

Related News:

What Bush’s invasion would look like in the United States….ld-look-like-in.html

Vanity Fair: Billions over Baghdad….currentPage=all

Poll: Civilian toll in Iraq may top 1M….ctrack=2&cset=true

Gates Wants US Troops to Spend MORE Time In Iraq

Were War Critic Soldiers Killed To Send Message?

Tommy Franks: Iraq May Require 10 or 20 More Years….0_more_years.php

GOP Leader: If We Defeat Al Qaeda, “We” Will Have Paid “A Small Price” In Iraq….er_boeh.php

Iraq Failing Half Of U.S. Benchmarks

Tom Friedman: “Suck on this, Iraq”

Bush tells Minister ‘we’re kicking ass’ in Iraq
U.S. Troops Thought Killing Civilians Was Legal
Thompson: ‘The Whole’ Middle East ‘Will Become Nuclearized’ If We Redeploy From Iraq
US strikes in Baghdad kill 14 sleeping civilians
Report: Air Force Lost 5 Nukes
Bush Wants $50 Billion More for Iraq War
Bush Hears About Strain on Troops
Iraqi Crude Oil Flowing Through Turkey
Couric Admits Her Rosy Report From Iraq Is Based On ‘What The U.S. Military Wants Me To See’
2nd Retired British General Slams US
All countries must stay course in Iraq, Bush tells Brown
British ex-army chief criticizes U.S. over Iraq
British anti-drug effort a failure: Afghan official
UK troops poised to quit Basra
Iraqi civilian deaths rise
Iraq to free thousands of jailed Sunnis
More Iraqis Flee as Figure Tops Four Million
Marines Ordered To Execute Civilians In Nazi-Like Slaughter
Congress: Iraq ‘surge’ not working
Marines Ordered To Execute Women/Children
U.S. Military Censors ThinkProgress
US says ready to step back into Basra as British pull out
200 journalists killed in Iraq war
US Government, Complicit in Iraq Corruption, Helps Punish Whistleblowers
Air Force Ready To Aid Insurgencies
American Whistleblowers Tortured – Lives And Careers Ruined By Their Own Government
Gen. Pace Denies Will Urge Troop Cut in Iraq


Comments are closed.

%d bloggers like this: